States Diverge on Vaccine Policy as Federal Guidance Shifts
Vaccine policy in the U.S. is undergoing major changes, and the result is a patchwork system where access and requirements vary dramatically depending on where you live. Here’s a breakdown of the most recent developments at the federal and state levels.
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) recently updated its guidance, authorizing COVID-19 vaccines only for adults aged 65+ and for younger adults and children with certain qualifying health conditions. This marks a shift away from the previous universal eligibility for all adults. At the same time, the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP)—which normally helps guide national vaccine recommendations — has been disbanded, leaving a gap in federal leadership.
State Responses Create Patchwork of Vaccine Access Policies
Restrictive State Policies Limit Pharmacy Vaccination Authority
Pharmacies are finding themselves constrained by state laws. For example, in Massachusetts, Nevada, and New Mexico, pharmacies cannot vaccinate anyone outside of FDA-defined eligibility—even with a doctor’s prescription. In about 16 other states, vaccination depends on both age and whether a patient has a prescription.
Progressive States Expand Vaccine Access Beyond Federal Guidelines
Some states are pushing back. For example, the Pennsylvania State Board of Pharmacy voted to accept guidance from trusted medical groups, which allows pharmacies to vaccinate more people than federal rules alone permit. New York Governor Kathy Hochul (D) has also issued an executive order that will allow pharmacists to administer COVID vaccines, providing access for all residents who wish to be vaccinated.
West Coast Alliance Develops Independent Immunization Framework
Meanwhile, California, Oregon, Washington, and now Hawaii have launched the West Coast Health Alliance. The coalition is writing its own science-based immunization guidance, independent of the federal government, to ensure access and maintain public trust.
Florida Moves to Eliminate All Vaccine Mandates
In stark contrast, Florida is moving to end all vaccine mandates, including those required for children attending school. Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo compared mandates to “slavery” and said the decision should rest between patients and their physicians. Governor Ron DeSantis and Republican lawmakers plan legislation to remove statutory mandates. Critics warn that rolling back requirements for diseases like chickenpox and hepatitis B could spark new outbreaks of preventable illnesses.
Future Implications of Divergent Vaccine Policies
As federal guidance narrows, states are splitting in different directions: some tightening access, others building independent frameworks, and some dismantling mandates altogether. The result is a confusing, uneven landscape that leaves patients, providers, and families struggling to navigate vaccine access at a critical moment for public health.
Track Health Care Policy with State Vitals
StateVitals is the leading resource on how state governments are shaping healthcare policy and transforming care and delivery, brought to you by MultiState’s Health Care Policy Practice. MultiState’s policy and advocacy professionals are uniquely positioned to give you and your organization the big-picture view on state health policy reform, plus the latest trends on how policymakers are thinking about healthcare and similar emerging issues. Learn more about StateVitals, or schedule a demo here.